What the Ideal Weight Estimate does
The Ideal Weight Estimate shows a healthy weight range for your height, based on body mass index, and the results of four classic formulas: Devine, Robinson, Miller and Hamwi. By default it uses the lower upper limit of BMI 22.9 that Indian guidelines advise for South Asians, which you can switch off to see the international range.
How to use it
- Choose your units and sex.
- Enter your height and your current weight.
- Leave the South Asian limit ticked, or untick it for the international BMI range of 18.5 to 24.9.
- Read the healthy range and the four formula results.
Example
For a woman 165 cm tall, a BMI of 18.5 to 22.9 means a healthy range of about 50.4 to 62.3 kg; with the international limit of 24.9 the top is about 67.8 kg. The formulas give 56.4 kg (Hamwi) to 59.8 kg (Miller). For a man 175 cm tall, the range is about 56.7 to 70.1 kg, and Devine gives 70.5 kg.
Why a range is better than one number
The named formulas were developed decades ago, mostly to work out medicine doses, and they ignore build, muscle and age. A healthy BMI range accepts that people of the same height can be healthy at different weights. Research shows people of South Asian origin face higher risks of diabetes and heart disease at lower BMIs, which is why Indian guidelines use 23 as the start of the overweight range.
Waist size is a useful second check: Indian guidelines suggest keeping it under 90 cm for men and 80 cm for women.
Questions people ask
Which formula is most accurate?
None is accurate for an individual. They mostly agree within a few kilograms; use them as a rough guide alongside the BMI range.
I am muscular and above the range. Is that a problem?
Not necessarily. BMI cannot tell muscle from fat. A body-fat estimate or waist measurement gives a better picture.
Does it work for children?
No. Children and teenagers need BMI-for-age growth charts.
Is this medical advice?
No. It is general information. Your doctor can advise on a healthy weight for you.